I am addressing this issue because I am sick and tired of people doing this, and it needs to be stopped, or at least tried to be stopped. It's not okay for people do be doing this. Sure, your personal opinion should be respected, but most of you are just doing this for the stupidest, most shallow reasons. Please read on.

Okay, to understand what I'm going to be talking about, you HAVE TO READ THIS ARTICLE in its entirety:

http://www.mtv.com/movies/news/articles/1613475/story.jhtml

Now do you people understand? Catherine Hardwicke isn't saying that she wants Robert and Kristen to try out ONLY for MR, but for this IF I STAY also!

Robert Pattinson; personally, I am not a fan of this guy, but I am not a hater either. He's alright with me. But, I don't think Hardwicke is that stupid to put Rob in MR. I don't know if there is a role for Rob in IF I STAY, since I never read it, but definitely not in MR. So CALM DOWN. If anything Hardwicke will give him a cameo role. Also, Hardwicke didn't say the names of ANY CHARACTERS FROM 'MAXIMUM RIDE' OR 'IF I STAY'. So that doesn't necessarily mean she want Rob and Kristen for Max and Fang (or any other characters in either book/series).

Now; Kristen Stewart. Personally, I love this chick. I am a huge fan of her's. She is stylish, beautiful, smart, nice and a GREAT actress. There; I said it. GREAT. For those of you Twilight fans who have only seen her in Twilight, just shut up. That role of Bella was not good to begin with (yes, I have read all four of the books). Bella is a big Mary Sue. Not one actress would be able to do her justice, because they are all better than that. Watch INTO THE WILD, CATCH THAT KID, IN THE LAND OF WOMEN, CUTLASS, PANIC ROOM, and all of her other movies, and tell me then what you think of Kristen's acting then. Enough with the "Oh she looks nothing like Bella" or "She had one expression all throughout the movie." Bella, in the books, was basically all the same, personality/expression-wise ( 'I blushed chagrid,' 'I stifled a gasp,' was said a heck of a lot by Bella through the series). So please don't give me that crap, Twilighters.

Personally, I wouldn't mind Kristen in the movie...and/or as Max. I think she could pull it off. Heck, she's playing badass Joan Jett in THE RUNAWAYS, I think she can play a badass Max. Do I think she is the best for the role of Max? Actually, no. Do I think she would be good as Max? YES. As big of a fan I am of her, I think it would be...interesting to see a fresh face that has a great deal of talent. Like a new Angelina Jolie (acting-wise). But Kristen would be good in the role, nevertheless. She could totally kick major Eraser-butt. Also, in the interview it said that there may be a role for Kristen in IF I STAY; not MR. Are we all calmed down now?!

Okay? So please stop bashing Kristen. She has quite a few movies coming up (like...five I think?), so I don't think she will be very able to pencil in MR. Leave the girl alone. Kristen herself isn't saying she wants to take the role, it's Hardwicke. If KStew isn't how you pictured Max, fine, it's your mental picture, but that doesn't give you the right to talk crap about her because she isn't how you pictured Max. How would you like it if you met your boyfriend's or girlfriend's family, and you were extremely anxious to meet them, and they said, "Oh, you aren't how I pictured my son's/daughter's girlfriend/boyfriend to be. Now I don't like you and never will." or "You don't act like how I think my son's/daughter's boyfriend/girlfriend should act. Go away."? Not good, I'd guess. The same thing goes for Kristen Stewart. That is what you are doing to her. She wouldn't like how you're treating her either. Give her a chance at least. You are just automatically shunning her for her looks/acting/age. And for those of you who are saying that Kristen is too old to play Max, on the contrary, she is right on target. Max described herself in Book 1 (which they will be filming/adapting) as being of the height of 5'8. Kristen is also 5'8. Max also described the Flock and herself as looking older than their actual age. So if Max looked about 19, and she is supposed to be14, that would be just perfect. So Kristen Stewart could be Max. So now, stop with these lame petitions and discussion threads and comments and all that stuff. Even if Kristen (or Rob) were casted, it isn't life or death; just re-read the books to console yourself from your worst nightmare casting and picture whoever you picture as your characters. You know what, if Kristen or Robert were casted in the movie, see it anyway. I'm sure it wil still be great.

For those of you, very few of you, who have no problem with Kristen Stewart in any way/matter at all including this MAXIMUM RIDE debate, I applaud you for being open enough to give Kristen a chance, or if you are just a fan. You are truly awesome people.

So: Kristen Stewart as Max?: Okay. Robert Pattinson as Fang?: No. He has the acting chops, but he is 25, and just not Fang. He isn't how JP described him. But, I will not bash him just because he doesn't look like Fang.

So, please. Stop bashing Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson. Give Kristen specifically, and Robert, a chance.



Please leave a comment stating your opinion on my discussion/this casting debate below.

Tags: catherine, fang, hardwicke, kristen, max, maximum, movie, mtv, pattinson, ride

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Hmm.... I have nothing against the two Twilight stars (other than the Twilight itself, but that's probably for another thread). However, I just do not see them as suitable for the roles of Max and Fang. They just don't fit the picture. Also, and I know this has been said before, IF either (and BOTH of them is definately out of the question) of them star as Max or Fang, Maximum Ride would indefinitely be linked with Twilight, and Maximum Ride should definitely start off with a clean, Twilight-fanatic-free slate.

Reply to This

Ya! stop bashing them! just cause they suke at acting doesn't mean we should mace fun of them.
But sierusly. If she plays max, i am going to arange a boycot. She has no emotion in twilight, why should she play an evan more divers charecter? She would die of pressure.

Reply to This

i dont mind if they audition for the role. i really think that twilight suits them better. i just think that they should cast nobodies, like people who arent famous, and see what happens :)
maximum ride is thee best!
love fang :)
- Sparrow

Reply to This

The following is strictly my opinion, but I felt a strong compulsion to share:

NO NO NO NO! Kristen Stewart is the worst actress in the world. She was good twice, Zathura and in the ballet scene in Twilight when she had to be all twitchy after she got bit by James. She's asleep in every single movie she does! RRRGGH! And others are right, she can't be Max because she's already known as Bella. She doesn't look like Max anyway.

Robert was good in Harry Potter. Much better looking too. The American accent ruined him in Twilight. British accents are much sexier.

But Kristen needs to stop acting and start modeling, because she's beautiful but has NO TALENT!

Rrgh, okay. I said my piece.

Reply to This

dude i think they should stay away from max and fang the act terrible i mean i liked it the first time i saw twillight but honestly now i freaking hate it ok

Reply to This

I actually signed a petition that robert and Kristen won't play in the maximum ride movie and Fang Has to be A HOT Emo dude or I will sue too he should look like the guy on book 2

Reply to This

there is NO WAY that either of them should play max or fang. NO WAY!!!!!!!!!

Reply to This

Cathrine Hardwick did a pretty sucky job on Twilight....I hope she dosen't mess up this Maximum Ride. :(

Reply to This

yah me too :(

Reply to This

Max is blonde. She had black hair. Why doesn't the girl on the front of the book covers be Max and the boy on the front of the covers be Fang? There's an idea. I don't want to "bash" her, but please not her. Someone unknown or something. She was good when she was young.

Reply to This

its called hair dye. second of all, the peolle on the covers are MODELS, not actors.

Reply to This

good point

Reply to This

RSS

Forum

brooke reed

When Do You Think Fang Started Liking Max? 377 Replies

Started by brooke reed in Max + Fang = Fax. Last reply by kaity belle reaves 4 minutes ago.

Casey Huffman

Killing Off Fang (Part One) 243 Replies

Started by Casey Huffman in Max + Fang = Fax. Last reply by Andrew 1 hour ago.

MusicAndAnime

Did anyone else get the free excerpt of Fang off of iTunes? 224 Replies

Started by MusicAndAnime in The 6th Max Ride. Last reply by Stepha-nay-nay 10 hours ago.

Emmy aka Wolfie (Dylan's Girl)

Fang: First twelve chapters are genius 460 Replies

Started by Emmy aka Wolfie (Dylan's Girl) in The 6th Max Ride. Last reply by Thunderspark 8 hours ago.

Sievey Kole Jackson

FANG NEW INFO 1110 Replies

Started by Sievey Kole Jackson in The 6th Max Ride. Last reply by Happily Ever After 9 hours ago.

© 2010   Created by Hachette Book Group USA

Badges  | Guidelines  |  Report an Issue  | Guidelines  |  Privacy  |  Terms of Service

Sign in to chat!